- Can we compare a car with AI with nature?
- Definition of intelligence and Nature
- Signs of a intelligent creator
- biosphere learning ability
- Has the biosphere ability to adapt to new situations ?
We talk today about intelligent vehicles , cars that can drive alone like e.g. Tesla or alert you about dangers. We have also intelligent homes that call you and the firemen if there is smoke or the police if someone is in your home.
There would be no intelligent vehicles at Tesla without intelligent car engineers at Tesla. In the same way, there would be no smart solutions for homes being sold by e.g. dlink without intelligent engineers at DLink.
Knowing that intelligence includes the ability to learn and adapt to new situations, the use of the adjective “intelligent” in “intelligent car” or “intelligent home” is totally misleading. Even if Artifical intelligence (AI) is planned for cars, there are today only tests being done with robots with AI.
When I talk about “intelligent Nature”, that doesn’t mean that Nature as a system is intelligent. It can also mean that there is a lot of intelligence in Nature.
So my first question is therefore…
A car is a assembly of different parts. We can not say that if a car has artificial intelligence butilt in it then all screws must be intelligent. The same with nature. Even if nature has intelligent animals this doesn’t mean that all organisms are intelligent. Being aware about that we can can compare a car with AI with the nature as a system, like the biosphere, a biosphere we know includes among others a ecosystem. I will look at the Biosphere in my article, when looking for intelligence in nature.
Evaluating the intelligence of the Biosphere it is important to know about what makes a brain intelligent. In the brain we have different “areas that work together to give us intelligence.” (Source: www.dailymail.co.uk/sciencetech )
So looking at the biosphere we have to study the different parts of the biosphere to see if these maybe together make the biosphere intelligent.
The issue “intelligent biosphere” is talked about by Drew Purves who present his conclusion about Nature and AI at https://channel9.msdn.com
Would there be an intelligent Biosphere without a intelligent Creator?
Before I proceed with this question is it important that we define intelligence and Nature a little more in depth.
According to www.merriam-webster.com
the definition of intelligence is
“the ability to learn or understand or to deal with or trying new situations“
intelligence is also in Christian Science “the basic eternal quality of divine Mind”
According to Drew Purves in his speech in https://channel9.msdn.com all organisms in our biosphere have intelligence according to his definition in the screen below.
Is this leading to the concusion that biosphere is intelligent? or
is this a proof that there is a lot of intelligence in our biosphere?
definition of Nature
defines Nature like this:
- “ the inherent character or basic constitution of a person or thing”
- creative and controlling force in the universe
- an inner force (such as instinct, appetite, desire) or the sum of such forces in an individual
Mariam Webster does not mention the Nature as it being discussed about as in this dialog:
Bill says: “Paul, you cannot say that mycelium is intelligent! You can’t say nature is intelligent.
Paul answers: Bill, I respect you, but you don’t realize the hypocrisy of the statement you’re giving me? You’re telling me nature is not intelligent and yet you are born of nature, using the mind to conceive the concept to challenge the idea that nature is not intelligent—when you are part of nature?” (Source: listed.standardnotes.org )
My article should really be called “A intelligent biosphere” as it is this I put focus on here.
- Are there signs of a intelligent creator in the Biosphere?
- Has the biosphere ability to learn and adapt to new situations ?
This is a question of endless struggle. On the one hand, nature obviously produced us, and it becomes troubling to say “that which produced something as intelligent as us is itself not intelligent”. On the other hand, chance, probability, randomness, and singularities play a huge part in modern science, and to question that would surely invite ridicule. (Source: listed.standardnotes.org )
Obviously you can not make this conclusion
Human being = intelligent
Human being = nature
Nature = intelligent
A very observant friend of mine told me that Nature shows many signs to be build by intelligence, in this case a intelligent God.
Here are a few of these examples.
- Many animals survive the winter deep down in holes. The trees loose their leaves during the winter not only to take care of the magnesiumin the clorophyll, but also to let the snow fall down and cover the ground avoiding the ground to freeze to deep and kill the animals hiding in it. And when there is no snow, the sunshine will heat up the ground. Te animals, mice andv insects that are up on the surface will find nutrition in the fallen leaves.
- Predators have the important function to keep arts from proliferating sickness and bad genes.
- With mutations there are probabilities that good characteristics may arise in a art.
- Bad characteristics are cleaned out by natures selectivity.
- As Giorando Bruno defined it 1599, all creatures have their role and significance.
- Some plants interact with bacteria to produce their own nitrogen fertilizer.
- When predators collaborate with their preys in Nature, as I wrote about in http://www.kinberg.net, we learn to love our enemies.
- ALl organisms have some sort of intelligence ( Source: Drew Purves in his speech in https://channel9.msdn.com )
I will try to answer this question looking at this similar question:
Have bacteria ability to learn?
Noone would consider a bacteria intelligent. But we all know that bacteria have developed resistance to antibiotics. Knowing about the natural mechanisms behind this, we understand that bacteria didnt learn to defend themselves from medicines even if it may look like that. So no, bacteria have no ability to learn. but through its frequent regeneration and mutations, bacteria have the possibility to adapt to new situations, that is the second definition of intelligence, adabtability. So if bacteria inherently are adabtive, may the biosphere as a system be adaptive too? I move onto this more specified question
My answer is yes. Here is my motivation.
Looking at the human burning of carbon fossils, we have now effects carbon cycle.
Due to the greenhouse effect we have also effects on the water cycle, with the melting of the Earth water reserves, the glaciers and with it the raise of sea levels. Earth has had very high levels of carbon dioxide once in a time.
With our carbon fossil burning, we are having our biosphere to adapt again to the previous ages of its development, e.g. the Cambrian era when the atmospheric carbon dioxide level was much higher.
Story of adaptation
The whole history of our biosphere is a history of adaptation.
What parts of the biosphere are involved in this adaptation?
Trees and algae, an important part in adaptation
The trees and the algae in the oceans are the most important parts as these immediately proliferate taking care of the carbon dioxide surplus.
Even if this is less important in this case, all cells have clocks built in to regulate their activity according to time of the day and the year.
Some even talk about intelligent trees as these talk to each other. (Source: https://www.ted.com )
Many humans will suffer and die but the Biosphere will adapt.
One could maybe say that the Biosphere adapt more easily than we human beings.
Cockroaches and insects are known to be more adaptive than most organisms. Cockroaches seem to be the organisms that may even survive a world nuclear war.
So if adabtability is a definition of intelligence then cockroaches are more intelligent than we are.
.so therefore the conclusion, Nature or our biosphere does not need human made AI. We may instead need AI to become better “shepherds” on this earth.
We need to learn from Nature to develop AI. Like https://deepmind.com/ seems to be doing,
We have a intelligent Nature/biosphere as
- the Nature has a lot of inherent intelligence
- the Nature has a high capacity to adapt to new situations.
We can not say however that the Nature or Biosphere as a system is able to learn even if many organisms in it are able to to do so.